Allen Burdick on RF Gain Compensation

The information on this page is from the article “A Visit to Benchmark Media Systems” by Hilary Paprocki, published in The Audio Amateur, issue 4, 1995.

The majority of the article is an interview with Allen Burdick, president of Benchmark. (Note: I especially enjoyed reading the article because I have a Benchmark DAC1 PRE in my system.) In response to a question about overhauling existing products in search of better sound, Allen Burdick had this to say on page 15:

One of the things we feel very strongly about is making our circuitry radio-frequency (RF)-proof. That’s not as easy as it might seem. I believe that most of the bite, the edge, the harshness of what we hear in various audio devices is a direct result of intermodulation distortion caused by RF. Radio frequency power is everywhere, and metropolitan areas are so heavily bombarded by it that it will stress any audio system in such a region. [More so now 16 years later -EW]

We know that FET-input op amps have less sensitivity to RF interference and are therefore less prone to create IMD. We also know that since all op amps are compromised with regard to their designed-in phase margin, RF-induced IMD occurs with circuits having little or no feedback compensation. I suspect, therefore, that once we have in hand an op amp with sufficient slew rate, bandwidth, linearity, and noise performance, the subtle difference that are audible–and the difference reviewers hear when substituting op amps–may be the result of inadequate feedback compensation around the amplifier stage, or other RF-induced IMD.

This means that audiophiles must know how to add feedback compensation to otherwise good amplified systems to prevent gain intersection with the open-loop curve of the op amp. It also necessitates some understanding of shielding practices.

RFI also requires audiophiles to have a good understanding of grounding principles, since RF really does not respect the grounding found in many, if not most, systems. RF power can easily be coupled to the signals looping between pieces of equipment unless grounding is properly executed. Ultimately, even though it is more expensive, I believe there needs to be a move to the balanced interconnect system, especially on inputs, as exists in the professional environment.

Hilary Paprocki expanded on this in the sidebar on page 12, reproduced here:

Allen Burdick sidebar on RF gain compensation, "Taming Op Amp Distortion"

Back to main article.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s